Fesenko Law Offices

1050 30th Street NW, Washington, DC 20007 TEL +1 202 821 2303
30 Wall Street, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10005 TEL +1 212 542 0240

  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

  • EN
  • RU

Fesenko Law Offices

1050 30th Street NW, Washington, DC 20007 TEL +1 202 821 2303
30 Wall Street, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10005 TEL +1 212 542 0240

  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

  • EN
  • RU

Fesenko Law Offices
  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

  • EN
  • RU

Fesenko Law Offices

1050 30th Street NW, Washington, DC 20007 TEL +1 202 821 2303
30 Wall Street, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10005 TEL +1 212 542 0240

  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

  • EN
  • RU

Fesenko Law Offices

1050 30th Street NW, Washington, DC 20007 TEL +1 202 821 2303
30 Wall Street, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10005 TEL +1 212 542 0240

  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

  • EN
  • RU

Fesenko Law Offices
  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

  • EN
  • RU

  • US Sanctions
    • OFAC Licenses Explained: What They Are and How They Work
    • Unblocking Assets Through Litigation: How to Recover Funds Frozen by U.S. Sanctions
    • OFAC SDN List Removal: A Petition First, Then Court If Needed
    • SDN List Removal Through Litigation While the Graham Act Is Waived
    • Representation of Clients Before OFAC: What an OFAC Attorney Actually Does
    • How to Stay Out of the OFAC Sanctions List
  • Business in the U.S.A.
    • Startup in the U.S.A.
    • Register a Company in the USA: Entity, State and What Comes After
      • Register an LLC in the USA: What to Decide Before You File
      • Register a Corporation in the USA: Shares, Board and the Filings That Follow
    • Proof of Source of Funds for a Bank
  • News
  • Why Fesenko Law Offices
  • Contact Us

Can You Obtain the OFAC Administrative Record Without Filing Suit?

May 13, 2026 US Sanctions
Home | US Sanctions | Can You Obtain the OFAC Administrative Record Without Filing Suit?

Table of Contents

  • Pre-Litigation Access: The Limits of the Administrative Stage
  • Why the Freedom of Information Act Does Not Solve the Problem
  • How APA Litigation Compels Disclosure of the Record
  • What the Unclassified Portion of the OFAC Administrative Record Contains
  • Practical Value of Reviewing the Record
  • Strategic Conclusion

Access to the case file, known in U.S. administrative practice as the administrative record, is one of the key questions in sanctions practice. The answer determines whether a designated party can build a focused legal position or must work blind, with only the agency’s general formulations to react to. The practical answer is short: the OFAC administrative record becomes available to a designated party only within a federal court proceeding. All other paths – administrative request, the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA, 5 U.S.C. § 552), counsel’s correspondence with the agency – yield either a very limited result or no result at all.

Pre-Litigation Access: The Limits of the Administrative Stage

At the administrative stage, before a lawsuit is filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (D.D.C.), the OFAC administrative record is unavailable to the designated party in any meaningful form. The Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) announces a designation by updating the Specially Designated Nationals (SDN) List, typically accompanied by a press release; a related notice is also published in the Federal Register, often with some delay. The press release may briefly reference the general grounds for designation: a connection to a sanctioned sector of the economy, affiliation with another SDN, or involvement in specific transactions. A critical nuance: neither the press release nor the Federal Register notice contains anything close to a detailed evidentiary basis for the decision.

When an administrative delisting petition is filed, OFAC may send the petitioner clarifying questions or a request for supplemental information. That, however, is a tool for the agency to extract information from the petitioner, not a mechanism for disclosure to the petitioner. OFAC’s response on the petition typically consists of a generic statement. The negative response, for instance, may state that the materials submitted are insufficient to warrant reconsideration. The specific documents underlying the conclusion of a designation, the intelligence-derived sources, the inter-agency correspondence — all of this remains outside what the petitioner sees.

The situation with asset freezes looks much the same. Clients learn that their assets have been blocked through a brief notification from the bank that froze them. The notification contains no details about the reasons for the freeze. Attempts to obtain more information from the bank typically yield no result either. The bank freezes the funds under its internal compliance policies, which it is under no obligation to disclose.

As a result, building a legal position at this stage proceeds through reconstruction: which factual assertions OFAC apparently treats as established, which sources it likely relied on, which legal characterizations it applies. This method works for a first-round petition but does not provide the foundation for targeted challenges.

Why the Freedom of Information Act Does Not Solve the Problem

A FOIA request seems like a logical next step, but applied to sanctions files its effectiveness is severely limited.

OFAC routinely applies the following exemptions to sanctions materials (FOIA, 5 U.S.C. § 552):

  • (b)(1) – information classified in the interest of national security;
  • (b)(3) – information protected by specific statutes, including materials shared by foreign governments;
  • (b)(5) – internal deliberative inter-agency communications;
  • (b)(7) – law enforcement records.

In practice, this means that the document set obtained through FOIA is either fully redacted (pages of solid black bars) or limited to publicly available correspondence and standard forms. FOIA processing times at OFAC run into months, often years on complex requests. Administrative appeals of redactions rarely yield meaningful results. FOIA is therefore not a working mechanism for obtaining the OFAC administrative record in a sanctions dispute.

How APA Litigation Compels Disclosure of the Record

The picture changes fundamentally once a lawsuit against OFAC is filed under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). Under the standard of judicial review on the administrative record (5 U.S.C. § 706), a court evaluates the agency’s decision based on the body of documents the agency relied on in making it. This means OFAC must file the full administrative record with the court – that is, compile and lodge all materials that formed the basis for the challenged decision.

After suit is filed, OFAC typically sends the court a notice of filing of administrative record within 60 to 90 days, accompanied by an index of documents. The unclassified portion is provided to the plaintiff and counsel. Classified portions are submitted to the judge ex parte and in camera (i.e., reviewed by the judge separately, without the plaintiff or counsel present). In D.D.C. practice, the court conducts an independent review of the classification justifications and, in some cases, may require the agency to prepare unclassified summaries for production to the plaintiff.

The volume and substance of what is disclosed depend on the nature of the case, but in most sanctions disputes the unclassified portion of the record substantially exceeds anything the petitioner has previously seen: specific sources become visible, the dates of the materials, the chains of agency reasoning, references to reports, correspondence, and open sources.

What the Unclassified Portion of the OFAC Administrative Record Contains

The unclassified portion of the OFAC administrative record in a typical sanctions dispute generally includes:

  • the designation memorandum setting out the factual grounds for inclusion;
  • open-source materials gathered by the agency: articles, corporate registries, databases;
  • financial and corporate information obtained from banking and regulatory sources;
  • Treasury internal correspondence and decision documents related to the case;
  • an index of classified materials with descriptions of their nature.

It is precisely this body of materials that reveals how OFAC characterized specific facts: which transactions it treated as evidence of control, which connections it deemed sufficient to apply the 50 percent rule, which sources it relied on to establish facts not supported by official corporate documentation.

Practical Value of Reviewing the Record

Analysis of the OFAC administrative record often becomes the turning point in a sanctions dispute. The key conclusions a petitioner and counsel draw from the materials:

  • what specific evidence underlies the decision and how strong it actually is;
  • which materials are stale or predate the events in dispute;
  • which conclusions rest on secondary or open sources of questionable quality;
  • which evidence submitted by the petitioner went unaddressed by the agency;
  • which procedural steps by OFAC are vulnerable to challenge under the arbitrary-and-capricious standard.

These findings make it possible to strengthen the position in the pending proceeding and to prepare a motion for summary judgment identifying specific defects in the administrative record and seeking remand to OFAC for reconsideration.

Often the very disclosure of the OFAC administrative record shifts the agency’s posture: confronted with the materials viewed from the outside, with counsel’s reaction to them, and with the resulting legal exposure, OFAC more frequently agrees to reconsider.

Strategic Conclusion

In sanctions practice, an APA suit against OFAC performs two functions. The first is the judicial challenge to the OFAC decision itself. The second, no less important – obtaining the OFAC administrative record needed to build a defense. The two functions reinforce each other: a serious lawsuit opens access to the record, and access to the record makes the lawsuit substantively credible.

For parties on the SDN List or facing a denial of an OFAC specific license, the implication is direct: the administrative path alone does not exhaust the real options. Filing suit, paired with a professionally prepared administrative petition, opens access to materials without which an effective defense is, in practice, impossible.

American attorney asset freeze OFAC OFAC administrative record OFAC sanctions OFAC SDN List OFAC specific license U.S. sanctions

Related Posts

Blocked vs Rejected Transaction: What a US Bank Does With Your Money Under OFAC Rules
US SanctionsNovember 13, 2026

Blocked vs Rejected Transaction: What a US Bank Does With Your Money Under OFAC Rules

The wire left your account and never reached the other side. A week later, the bank sends two lines: the payment was stopped under regulations administered by the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) of...

View More
When Russia Sanctions Will Be Lifted: Five Years, a Peace Condition and the Graham Act Waiver
US SanctionsNovember 12, 2026

When Russia Sanctions Will Be Lifted: Five Years, a Peace Condition and the Graham Act Waiver

After October 16, the headlines were simple: Trump had paused the new Russia sanctions. Plenty of readers took that as a sign that relief was on its way, and the question we now hear most is when Russia...

View More
OFAC Secondary Sanctions: Why Foreign Banks Will Now Reject Payments Faster
Business in the USAUS SanctionsNovember 7, 2026

OFAC Secondary Sanctions: Why Foreign Banks Will Now Reject Payments Faster

A wire routed through Dubai or Istanbul comes back with two words: "compliance reasons." The counterparty isn't on any list you checked, the goods are ordinary, and the bank won't say anything else. Expect...

View More
Source of Funds Legal Opinion: When a Client’s Explanation Isn’t Enough for the Bank
Business in the USAUS SanctionsOctober 30, 2026

Source of Funds Legal Opinion: When a Client’s Explanation Isn’t Enough for the Bank

Consider a typical case. The bank has come back a second time. You answered the first request properly: a detailed letter on where the money came from, when you sold your stake, and why the wire went...

View More
Previous Post
Next Post
How Can We Support You? Get in touch with us to find out more or make an appointment. Get in Touch

Categories

  • Business in the USA
  • Inheritance in the US
  • US Sanctions

Popular

  • OFAC Delisting Petition Documents: What Works and What Gets Ignored
    US Sanctions

    OFAC Delisting Petition Documents: What Works and What Gets Ignored

  • U.S. Oil Sanctions: The Russia Card
    US Sanctions

    U.S. Oil Sanctions: The Russia Card

  • Delaware Corporation Registration: Who Needs It and Who Does Not
    Business in the USA

    Delaware Corporation Registration: Who Needs It and Who Does Not

  • OFAC general license for Russian oil: GL 134B replaces GL 134A
    US Sanctions

    OFAC general license for Russian oil: GL 134B replaces GL 134A

  • OFAC License Application Mistakes and How to Fix Them with an Amendment
    US Sanctions

    OFAC License Application Mistakes and How to Fix Them with an Amendment

Tags

50 percent rule Alfa Group American attorney American lawyer Anatoly Karachinskiy asset blocking asset freeze business in the USA How to Open a US Company how to open business in the USA Lukoil sanctions OFAC OFAC attorney OFAC general license OFAC lawyer OFAC license OFAC sanctions OFAC SDN OFAC SDN List OFAC SDN List removal OFAC specific license OFAC subpoena register a company Removal from the OFAC SDN List sanctions attorney sanctions compliance sanctions on Russian oil SDN list SDN OFAC SPB Exchange start a business in the USA U.S. sanctions U.S. sanctions list US bank account US bank account for foreigners US company US Department of Commerce US LLC US Russia-Related sanctions US sanctions US sanctions against Russia US sanctions compliance US sanctions list US startup РСПП

Disclaimer

All content provided on FesenkoLaw.com is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish any attorney-client relationship. The owner of this site makes no representations as to the accuracy or completeness of any information on this site and will not be liable for any possible errors or omissions.

Fesenko Law Offices, P.C.

OFAC SANCTIONS

  • Legal Representation by OFAC Lawyers
  • OFAC Licenses for Asset Unfreezing
  • OFAC Sanctions Compliance

OFAC SDN LIST

  • Challenging OFAC SDN List Designations
  • OFAC SDN List Removal
  • How to Stay Out of the OFAC SDN List

OFAC LITIGATION

  • Representation of Clients before the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia
  • Judicial Challenges to OFAC SDN List Designations
  • Asset Unfreezing through U.S. Federal Court

OPENING BUSINESS IN THE U.S.A.

  • Company Registration in the U.S.A.
  • Startup Formation in the U.S.A.
1050 30th Street NW, Washington, DC 20007 TEL +1 202 821 2303
30 Wall Street, 8th Floor, New York, NY 10005 TEL +1 212 542 0240
Mail info@fesenkolaw.com
Get in Touch
© 2026 FesenkoLaw.com. All rights reserved. | Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Privacy policy
GDPR Cookie Banner

We use cookies to optimize our website performance, to improve functionality and to analyze traffic. By clicking “Accept necessary” or by closing this message you agree to accept the necessary cookies which are essential for the operation of the website. If you choose to “Accept All” you agree to accept analytics cookies as well.

FesenkoLaw.com
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance (opens in a new tab)
Cookie Files Policy

Your privacy is important to us. We use cookies to make our website work more efficiently for you. Cookies are small data files that are placed on your device the first time you visit a website. We only use strictly necessary cookies that are essential for the website to function, and cookies to analyze website traffic and visited pages.
Our website uses two types of cookie files:
1) Strictly necessary
2) Analytics cookies

Strictly necessary

These cookies are essential for technical reasons to enable our website to operate. Because these cookies are necessary, you cannot refuse them without affecting how our services work. You can block or delete them by changing your browser settings, but keep in mind that this may limit the functionality of our website services.

Analytics cookies

These cookies collect information about how visitors use our website, such as which pages they go to most often and whether they receive error messages. They don’t collect information that identifies a visitor; we use it strictly to fix problems and improve how our website works.